Peter’s Take is a weekly opinion column. The views and opinions expressed in this column are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ARLnow.com.
Last month, I wrote a column explaining why Virginia needs effective ethics reform. The Virginia legislature has adjourned without enacting it.
Why is this so hard for them? It’s because too many Republican and Democratic legislators continue to thumb their noses at the need for reform.
Here’s a small sampling of the attitudes they bring to the task:
- The only reason that the legislation was considered in the first place is because “the media is on our backs.” Sen. Majority Leader Tommy Norment, R-James City
- “[T]he Senate, I think, was rightly concerned about … feeding the public perception that we’re all crooks somehow, which we are not.” Del. Todd Gilbert, R-Shenandoah (h/t Richard Nixon)
- “[Y]ou can’t legislate ethics.” Sen. Minority Leader Dick Saslaw, D-Fairfax
Contrary to Senator Saslaw, ordinary citizens do believe you can legislate ethics. Saslaw’s variation on the discredited refrain, “you can’t legislate morality”, misses the point. Here’s Princeton University’s Micah Watson in a piece titled “Why we can’t not legislate morality.”
One can no more avoid legislating morality than one can speak without syntax. One cannot sever morality from the law. Even partisans of the most spartan libertarian conception of the state would themselves employ state power to enforce their vision of the common good…The real question is not whether the political community will legislate morality; the question is which vision of morality will be enforced…
Many other states have passed much tougher ethics laws than Virginia. That further undermines what our legislators have just done.
The 49-page ethics bill that the legislature passed at the eleventh hour of the session includes a whole host of loopholes, including:
- The current ethics law sets a cumulative annual aggregate $250 cap on gifts by a lobbyist to any single legislator. But, unbelievably, the new ethics bill’s $100 cap is not cumulative. That means that a lobbyist can give an unlimited number of $99 contributions to a single legislator during the year, so long as each gift is given at a different point in time. Example: $99 per day for each of 365 days per year = $36,135 of legal gifts to any Virginia legislator (Call it the “buy your own Rolex” provision).
- A lobbyist can pay the full cost to fly a legislator from any location in Virginia to Richmond — so long as the purpose of the trip is official business. The cost of the trip is not counted against the $100 cap.
- The bill fails to establish an Ethics Commission with the power to issue subpoenas, assess fines for violations, and make referrals to the Attorney General or other prosecutors.
Conclusion
Those politicians who say they are proud of this latest ethics bill are deluding themselves and the public.
Peter Rousselot is a former member of the Central Committee of the Democratic Party of Virginia and former chair of the Arlington County Democratic Committee.